- Sept 30 Stocks/Final Small Grain Report Analysis:
- 2018/19 US Corn End Stocks; Average Estimate 2,436 million bu – Actual 2,114 million bu
- 2018/19 US Soybean End Stocks; Average Estimate 980 million bu – Actual 913 million bu
- 2019 US All Wheat Production; Average Estimate 1,971 million bu – Actual 1,962 million bu
- NASS September Stocks and Final Winter wheat production totals were bullish. The big surprises came from 2018/19 US corn and soybeans stocks that came in well below trade expectations. Chicago values have rallied sharply on the news and the data places much more importance on the Oct 11 US crop production report. The bears will be unable to sustain much downside price until US 2019 corn and soybean yields are better known.
- NASS revised down 2018 US soybean production by a record 116 million bu with yield down 1.0 bushels/acre to 50.6 bushels/acre. Planted area was pegged at 89.2 million acres (300,000 acres less) with harvested area down 400,000 acres at 87.6 million acres.
- US September 2018/19 corn stocks at 2,114 million bu came in 322 million less than expected by .the trade due to enlarged feed/residual use. Q4 US corn feed/residual is estimated by us at 1,039 million bu, a record. For wheat, June-August wheat feeding is estimated at 194 million bu vs 189 million last year.
- It is apparent that NASS had a real issue in estimating last year’s US corn and soybean crops. Analysts argued that they were too high, and were proven correct in the end. The 2018 US soybean yield decline was 2.5% or 116 million bu. A 2.5% drop in last year’s US corn crop amounts to 360 million bu, slightly more than the 322 million bu decline. The point is that it is likely that both 2018 US corn/soy crops were overstated by 2.5%. It is just that corn will be big upward adjustment to 2018/19 corn feed/residual. The 2018 US corn yield should be 172.8 bushels/acre, a drop of 3.6 bushels/acre, which will not be reported by NASS.
- The final 2019 US all winter wheat crop was 1.96 million bu, up from a revised total of 1.89 million bu in 2018. The US wheat yield was estimated at 51.6 bushels/acre, up 4.0 bu from the prior year. Winter wheat production accounted for 1.3 billion bu (up 10%) with spring wheat at 600 million bu (down 4%), and durum wheat (down 26%). US SRW production was 239.2 million bu, US HRW 833.2 million bu with US white production at 231.6 million bu. US HRS production amounted to 558.9 million bu. The wheat production data is viewed as slightly bullish to Chicago values.
- The September Stocks Report data does little, if anything, to bolster future confidence in USDA analysis. The big miss in US 2019 US corn and soybean stocks begs the question of their 2018 crop size analysis. Our bet is that NASS missed both the US corn and soybean crop sizes by 2.5% due to cold/wet harvest weather last autumn.
- Chicago prices are unlikely to decline until it is confirmed that US corn and soybean yields are equal to or larger than their September NASS forecasts. We see the upside price potential as $3.90-4.10 basis December corn and $9.10-9.25 basis November soybeans. The upside in December Chicago wheat is pegged at $5.05-5.15.
- S American weather becomes more important going forward as US and world soybean production has fallen 3 million mt in soybeans and 8.2 million mt in corn. The NASS September report does not change long held bearish opinions, just that the upside is raised via the loss of US old crop supply and the uncertainty of new crop US yields in the early harvest.